01-18-2018, 11:56 PM
That's strange.
The commentator of "tv-serienjunkies" does not like this episode (only 1,5 from 5 possible points), but the audience likes it.
My favorite comments:
' At least there was again the pairing Sheldon / Penny to see, which is the only one of this series still works every time.On the other hand, it was again to be seen that Penny and Leonard have nothing in common. After all, Penny has limited understanding of science when Sheldon talks to her about it.'
'It was all there, which was so much fun in the beginning. Science-practical, compulsive Sheldon and the music story was also quite funny.'
'And the Bert-song from the perspective of the famous ball from the opening scene of the first Indy-movie is also a deeply nerdy, imaginative idea. I just found the plot annoying because Raj and Howard have become so disagreeable characters. Why do the scriptwriters make Howard to a father when he can not identify with the role? In the plot with Leonard and Amy, one wonders why they are not together? The part of the episode then manage to save Sheldon and Penny with their memorable chemistry.' 
BTW: Tuesday Pajamas Wrote:
'.....so I'm thinking our rogue (if there is one) is Broccolo'
If that is true than is is the first writer since a long time which recalls one of the original strengths of the show ("Shenny").
So I think why should not we call him from now our... "ROGUE ONE"?
The commentator of "tv-serienjunkies" does not like this episode (only 1,5 from 5 possible points), but the audience likes it.
My favorite comments:
' At least there was again the pairing Sheldon / Penny to see, which is the only one of this series still works every time.On the other hand, it was again to be seen that Penny and Leonard have nothing in common. After all, Penny has limited understanding of science when Sheldon talks to her about it.'
'It was all there, which was so much fun in the beginning. Science-practical, compulsive Sheldon and the music story was also quite funny.'
'And the Bert-song from the perspective of the famous ball from the opening scene of the first Indy-movie is also a deeply nerdy, imaginative idea. I just found the plot annoying because Raj and Howard have become so disagreeable characters. Why do the scriptwriters make Howard to a father when he can not identify with the role? In the plot with Leonard and Amy, one wonders why they are not together? The part of the episode then manage to save Sheldon and Penny with their memorable chemistry.'
BTW: Tuesday Pajamas Wrote:
'.....so I'm thinking our rogue (if there is one) is Broccolo'
If that is true than is is the first writer since a long time which recalls one of the original strengths of the show ("Shenny").
So I think why should not we call him from now our... "ROGUE ONE"?