12-20-2015, 09:02 AM
I have not seen the episode ( I will not) , but after everything I 've read here (concerning the behavior of Sheldon )……hmm…
….excuse me, but the whole sounds for me more than would ‘Mister Data’ play a program of his emo- chip. It does not sound like romance or love, but simply and only as a duty.
(By a character like ‘Al Bundy’ this was funny, but by Sheldon?…
…please.)
And under this point of view the thing has a large catch. To feel obliged to something personal has Sheldon only if the other person has done before something appropriate. (Like the many gift baskets and the hug after Penny given him the napkin-a scene that today still has the same power as before).
And I cannot remember that Amy has ever done something for Sheldon (except to importune him and to try to change his personality) that could explain or justify something like THAT now.
Sorry writers, but this whole thing is just as illogical, implausible and unbelievable like ‘the laundry-fantasy’ or the ‘love-experiment’. It is a desperate attempt to reconcile Sheldon's behavior in this episode with his traditional character. And as you all have described it ,….. it is an absolute flop.
It is really terrible, but it is also ones more ridiculous and one reason more for the authors to be ashamed.
Greetings from Germany!
P.S.: I stand to my opinion that Penny would be the only woman with which Sheldon would really feel something in this context
. He has broken his rules-like driving car-for her because he wanted it, and not because he saw it as an obligation. That was really affection. 
.... And I am still thinking that the possibilities for our ‘Shenny’ are not over now.
….excuse me, but the whole sounds for me more than would ‘Mister Data’ play a program of his emo- chip. It does not sound like romance or love, but simply and only as a duty.
(By a character like ‘Al Bundy’ this was funny, but by Sheldon?…
…please.)And under this point of view the thing has a large catch. To feel obliged to something personal has Sheldon only if the other person has done before something appropriate. (Like the many gift baskets and the hug after Penny given him the napkin-a scene that today still has the same power as before).
And I cannot remember that Amy has ever done something for Sheldon (except to importune him and to try to change his personality) that could explain or justify something like THAT now.
Sorry writers, but this whole thing is just as illogical, implausible and unbelievable like ‘the laundry-fantasy’ or the ‘love-experiment’. It is a desperate attempt to reconcile Sheldon's behavior in this episode with his traditional character. And as you all have described it ,….. it is an absolute flop.
It is really terrible, but it is also ones more ridiculous and one reason more for the authors to be ashamed.
Greetings from Germany!
P.S.: I stand to my opinion that Penny would be the only woman with which Sheldon would really feel something in this context
. He has broken his rules-like driving car-for her because he wanted it, and not because he saw it as an obligation. That was really affection. .... And I am still thinking that the possibilities for our ‘Shenny’ are not over now.