SPOILERS: The Elegant Universe- An In-depth Review/Analysis - Printable Version +- Shenny HQ (https://shennyhq.co.uk/dir) +-- Forum: Everything else (https://shennyhq.co.uk/dir/forumdisplay.php?fid=6) +--- Forum: Big-Balled Raccoons (https://shennyhq.co.uk/dir/forumdisplay.php?fid=12) +--- Thread: SPOILERS: The Elegant Universe- An In-depth Review/Analysis (/showthread.php?tid=379) |
The Elegant Universe- An In-depth Review/Analysis - Shintaro Kozu - 08-24-2015 Shintaro Kozu's in-depth review/analysis of The Elegant Universe by Nyx Underwood THIS IS GOING TO BE LONG, SO I HAVE BROKEN IT INTO SECTIONS THAT ARE EASILY DISTINGUISHABLE FOR YOUR PURPOSES AND CONVENIENCE.
ALSO THERE WILL BE DIRECT QUOTATIONS FROM THE FICTION THAT MIGHT BE SPOILERISH. READ WITH CAUTION AND KNOW WHAT YOU CAN TAKE AND CAN'T. Hello fellow Forum-ites, I'm Shintaro Kozu, and whilst I am still relatively new, I would like to at least contribute something to this wonderful place(since I think that you guys will be greatly contributing to my writing) by at least giving you my opinions of certain fictions. Of course, many people have done similar things, and there is a wonderful fiction recommendation thread located in the same section as this review (In fact, The Elegant Universe is listed in Post #3 of that thread by the poster queenoftheDales and I am positive it is listed in the very impressively comprehensive Fanfiction collection started and maintained by the poster Nutz, even if I myself can't locate its specific location in the collection. They deserve a fair few shout outs from other posters, and this is mine). A lot of you have no doubt perused both the thread and the collections to your heart's content and if you haven't its HIGHLY reccomended, but I find that an in-depth review on why something (in this case, a particular fiction) is good is as enjoyable as the something itself (often times, in-depth reviews have enhanced my perspective of the fan-created universe I have had the honor of stepping into). This is why I am going to be as comprehensive as possible to the point that many of you may (and probably will) find excessive. Also, it is my goal to give you the best review possible, so its as much a personal is it is a professional desire. I highly doubt (to the point of near absolute certainty) that I will do this for EVERY fiction that I read because of time and my own obligations (I.E School, studies for school, clubs, writing my own fiction, blogging and not to mention sexytimes ). However, I do have plans on doing a lot of the fiction that has inspired me in my writing and what I hope to achieve with it along with some that really stand above the rest (in this particular fiction's case, its both). I feel compelled to repeat (in case you don't read bold, contrasting letters ) that there will be spoilers, but I doubt that they will be anything that will completely and utterly ruin the experience for you (but I can't say for sure). Still, I will try to use a spoiler tag as much as possible or, failing that, notify you ahead of time of an impending spoiler. So without further ado, lets get to it! General Thoughts of the fiction First and foremost, I would like to say that this fiction is one of the best things I have had the honor to read in a long time. Not only is the plot deep, but the author allows each character to be portrayed exactly in-character whilst abandoning the "comedy" atmosphere that show and several authors have perfected (Namely JLynnB, I'll review her (his?) stuff later as well). While an atmosphere that is reminiscent of the show is a huge positive for most fictions (just read JLynnB's work), in this case, the opposite holds true. This is a much more serious story, which realistic characters, realistic emotions, and nothing really played for comedy (the comedic elements that do appear are used more as tools to enhance the "in-character-ness" of the characters in the fanfiction, which is very important in my opinion). The Elegant Universe takes the characters that we know and love and translates them (Almost transports them, really) into a more realistic medium, where their emotions and scenarios aren't just for laughs. Another great aspect of the fiction in question is the effective use of the prose. It is sophisticated, and deeply engaging. In the first chapter, we get a rather moving glimpse into Sheldon's past, and there are a myriad of very notable quotes like: Quote:That thirst to learn more, that unwavering desire to understand, to make sense of, to hold the entire universe in his hand and know its terrifying beauty: that desire became the single point that Sheldon Cooper marched towards, compass in hand.and: Quote:It was a complex hatred, one that was borne of realising that Nature gifts some with greater tools than others – knowing, some for the first time, that no matter how hard they worked, how desperately they wanted it, this strange little kid with a small train figurine always clutched in his little fist would always have what they lacked. You can clearly see the immense detail that the author goes into (with his flowing word choice that just seems too perfect) when trying to establish Sheldon. He does this effectively, and this is done throughout the fiction, which leads me to another topic: characterization. I'll first start with Sheldon and then one section to cover (briefly) the others. I would like to point out that my intention with giving Sheldon his own section while lumping the other characters into one is not to belittle the other characters in this fiction. They are all deeply explored (Penny as equally as Sheldon), and are keeping within the really high standard of characterization that the fiction has shown with the Whackadoodle. The reason I separated the two is to point out something else that the fiction does extremely well, it makes a strange character like Sheldon (as he is portrayed in the show and in other fictions) understandable (but still not relatable) to the readers, which is as noteworthy as it is difficult. The other characters are relatable (or at least were relatable) to some degree. Penny's purpose in the show is specifically to be an Everyman-esque character. To have a normal perspective amongst abnormal people. Leonard's faults and mistakes are at least reminiscent of many of the inexperienced with women. Howard is the one guy we ALL know that can turn anything and everything into an innuendo or a line. Raj, too, is relatable in the fact that he is shyness with women personified. All four characters have done, thought, or experienced something that the reader or audience can connect with. This makes perfect sense, as the TV show would like to hit as many demographics as possible in order to gain more viewers and keep them (example: Raj's attitude with romance and reading books commonly associated with women, and often reminiscent of a homosexual man). Sheldon is exactly the opposite, which makes him more significant in my opinion. His purpose, it seemed was to be unrelatable, unique, special, exotic I dare say. Sheldon drew a nice contrast with the rest of the characters, and this contrast is why I believe he became so successful. He's popular because Sheldon Lee Cooper was like no-one the majority of the audience had ever experienced before. Sheldon is popular because he stands out amongst even a unique crowd. However, the recent seasons have slowly dwindled (rather successfully it seems) that uniqueness away (much to the horror of many Shenny shippers or Vintage Sheldon purists like myself). The Elegant Universe honors the Vintage Era by fully taking place with its establish timeline, and makes numerous references that makes the old, familiar, and likable characters come alive with his characterizations that enhances rather than does away with their established personalities. That's why its stands above some of the other well-written fictions, it reminds me of the good times without it feeling forced. The Elegant Universe is one of the only fictions where that unique, beautiful creature named Sheldon Cooper is celebrated fully and one of the only fictions where maybe (if it was properly finished) we could become acquainted with again. Sheldon One of the good things about this fiction, something I particularly enjoy, is that it makes Sheldon seem more real, rather than a reiteration of the canon Sheldon or a Vintage Sheldon. Nyx also does a wonderful job of referencing the show's Sheldon as well as adding his unique additions to his character(mainly done through flashbacks) throughout the fic, see here (This quote spoils the season three opener, and not the fic iself, so I believe its safe to read): Quote:In three months, Howard, Raj and (this still brought a pang) Leonard had taken this identity and torn it neatly in half. This quote illustrates how the author painstakingly and ingeniously crafts a Sheldon that conforms beautifully with the show(at least from seasons 1-2) as well as a Sheldon that is unique and fresh to the reader. This fic really goes the extra mile with Sheldon. Every chapter has a glimpse at him, past and present (2009 which is the present in the fiction). It shows his struggles with not fitting in, being the black sheep of the family, and other such occurrences. All of this helps cement the multi-dimensional character that Sheldon is, a multi-dimensional character that the show only hints at (again, because of the show's comedic purpose). I am going to give you an example of this by taking a scene from Chapter 2 (its a flashback scene which the fiction distinguishes by a Line break accompanied by a date, time and location of the setting). NOTE: if, for some reason, you don't feel like reading it (the quote is really effective [I would argue more so] when you read the whole chapter along with it), you can skip the obvious quote distinction and just read my thoughts on it, which will be written in a manner that doesn't absolutely require you to know it.
Quote:3 March 1991, 4.30pm The above quote cements who Sheldon is, an emotional person who just has emotions about different things. Most people know how dedicated he is to science (Even the show depicts that fairly well), but this fiction, by this quote, does extra and tries to depict (convincingly) just how in love and emotionally invested he is in learning, science and his future. This started young, as we suspected and as the show hinted, but it was, again, something never really seen in the show. That's one the greatest beauties of fanfiction as a whole, it allows you access to things that was never within the scope of the original work. It also not only displays Sheldon as younger, but still remarkably in-line with what we can expect from his past on the show. The quote also accurately, beautifully and realistically displays excitement, blending the principles of showing the reader and telling the reader, in order to achieve the author's desired affects. I say affects because that's the mark of a good work of fiction. Only in good work of fiction can the reader come to many different conclusions, learn many different characteristics and embody many emotions or stances whilst reading only one scene. This fiction accomplishes that consistently throughout. This fiction also explains his first brush with science (Sheldon's brain is wired perfectly for science, but his brain is useless and wasted if he isn't exposed to it) in Chapter One in a beautifully written and relevant flashback (Not separated by a line break, because of its importance to the main idea of the first section in chapter). I would like to give an example of how that scene affected Sheldon (I'm leaving the scene out because it, along with the first chapter, deserves to be read in its entirety). FEEL FREE TO SKIP THE QUOTE BELOW IF YOU WANT TO AVOID EMOTIONAL SPOILERS (IF YOU ARE TOTALLY AGAINST SPOILERS OF ANY KIND, IT WOULD BE IN YOURS BEST INTERESTS TO SKIP ALL QUOTES UNLESS OTHERWISE STATED
Quote:There, in the living room of his house in Galveston, Texas, Sheldon Cooper found a single point of order in chaotic reality...For the first time, he had found something that he didn't understand right away. For the first time, he had a puzzle that actually made him take pause for a moment. This explanation emphasizes Sheldon's emotional response to an event that might seem rather insignificant to some of us, but this seemingly insignificant event is a moment that will shape Sheldon forever. Let's compare this with a quote from another work. We'll use my own fiction, Entropy (Chapter 1), which tries to attempt something similar. This, dear reader, you may read without fear of spoiling the fiction. Quote:If Sheldon ever came close to what people consider a 'religious experience', it happened on April 17, 1982. Notice the different styles? I would like you to make note on how the event in The Elegant Universe is described and how it also makes equal effort to cement the emotional consequences through its unique prose, while Entropy mainly focused on using a particular event, in different prose (less elegant, in my opinion), to explain a certain behavior as well as to introduce a practical plot point (Which I cut out to save space). Entropy focused less on how that event made Sheldon feel, and more on introducing a rationale behind a behavior common to Sheldon. Similar events, different purposes, different focuses, different style, and different reactions from readers. That's why, regardless of if you have read an even vaguely similar fiction that deals with the Season 3 opener commonly referred to as The Artic (The North Sea Nullification is the only one I remember off the stop of my head) it is still very much in your best interests to read this wonderful masterpiece because it offers a very rich, very relatable and a very believable Sheldon. But what about the others? Other Characters This fiction spends and crafts every main character in its narrative with the same care as it did with Sheldon. Penny gets almost equal time as Sheldon (we see her past as well within the context of the story), and, surprisingly, we are given the unique privilege of getting Leonard's perspectives/emotions at times (This is very important, and I'll address it later). We also see character growth in Raj and Howard respectively. I will not give you quotes of these, because I personally believe it is very much in your best interests to read an digest it in its entirety. The dialogue is spot on, and The Elegant Universe does a wonderful job of not painting ONE person as the "villain" but the majority of the characters as victims of their own insecurities. This is something that a lot of fictions I have read blatantly ignore, or forget to do, and it really can cost them in my opinion. Sometimes, in fact, more often than not, the antagonists in real life aren't in your way because they are bad, but because their interests are in direct conflict with yours, or their faults are driving the conflict. I'm going to be honest here and say that most Shenny people LOVE to simply write in a bad, jerk Leonard with no other explanation to his motives other than that he is an asshat. Some of it justified, but other things are never fully explained. This fiction does away with that and makes the admirable and successful try at explaining the thought processes behind Leonard's actions and thoughts, so that while you may not agree with him, you can at least understand why he does what he does, why he feels what he feels and more importantly, why he clings on to Penny. I'll give you an example of this, to illustrate my point: Spoiler
Quote:"I can help you," Leonard said gently as Sheldon reorganized the papers on the desk. There are no words to describe the feelings the author conveys with Leonard. They are relatable to those that have insecurities, even if his insecurities are extreme. Do you also see how the author make's sure to say that Leonard does indeed feel guilty. Just by adding his guilt, but allowing his faults and insecurities to get the best of him, it makes Leonard that much more of a real character, and a real antagonist. This is consistent throughout the narrative, and even Leonard gets character development in the end. This fiction does all the character immense justice. Thats why its one of the very few that I keep coming back, and one of the very few I recommend to even shamy or undecided shippers. Usually, I find myself, in most fictions, clearly rooting against Leonard (because he is almost invariably not The Good Guy), but this one had me be more sympathetic to him because of the added benefit of this glimpse, to the point where there was no clear bad guy. The Elegant Universe allowed me, the reader, to relate to Leonard, which made me invested in the story, and that made it difficult to demonize or villainize him (which again only benefitted the story in my opinion). Also, the author made him feel guilt for his actions towards Sheldon (rightly so), but his insecurities and his pride prevent him from fronting up to it. Again, more realistic and relatable than him refusing to take responsibility because he is just an entitled ass. Another wonderful thing about this fiction is that it doesn't paint Leonard as the only fallible, morally ambiguous character either. In fact, Penny is shown in a light of putting up with Leonard because its easy and safe. Again, this adds more dimensions to the characters that shape who they are and make them more real than some other fictions where its all fluff and circumstance. Not everything Penny and Sheldon do are perfect, and that adds more depth. I haven't read a fiction yet that has actually striven and succeeded in making the character of the show this real. The characterization might be the fiction's stand out achievement. Plot The plot, which FINALLY addressed REALISTICALLY the aftermath and implications of the season 3 opener, is engaging and rather emotionally driven (with a perfect amount of action to drive it forward). This is important as the plot is overwhelmingly a major factor in ALL of literature (I would argue the most important factor). However, even with this admission, I put the plot after characterization because fanfiction is unique medium which emphasizes characterization more so than other forms of literature (Because it is generally a rule of thumb that in order for the particular fanfiction to be believable, the characterization has to be, at the very least, reminiscent of the official work). The fiction's plot is, along with many of its aspects, realistic and flowed at a steady pace without seeming too rushed or too dragged out. Its also very unique and appealing to me personally because it addresses one of my main heartbreaks with the show: The circumstances that were revealed in the season 3 opener, as I mentioned above. The beginning of season three appalled me, maybe more so than most. It gave me a nasty taste in my mouth an a stomach full of tight knots because I, unlike some of the more casual viewers, fully realized the implications of what exactly it was that the three friends of Sheldon had done (because I want to be a scientist, and am an avid science fan and advocate). Experimental accuracy is paramount in science, as reputation. What most people don't understand is how competitive the scientific community really is. Rival researchers are CONSTANTLY trying to prove other scientists wrong (because better your reputation for accuracy is, the more money your team or project you will be likely to receive). The system is competitiveness because the competition highly encourages and is more likely to produce accurate results. The fact that they TAMPERED with an experiment and RUINED Sheldon's reputation (Because he bragged about it, and honestly, who couldn't blame him, the data seemingly proved the verification of STRING THEORY!). This selfish act likely impacted Sheldon's career seriously. Not only was it a professional slight, it was a MIDDLE FINGER to him and everything he stood for. This was grossly glossed over in the show (Because its a COMEDY), but this fiction put's the offense front and center, and addresses the action the characters took. In the fiction, it not only rationalizes the actions taken by the characters in the aftermath of the incident (namely Sheldon's acceptance of the apology), but it, in my opinion, realistically shows how this breaks my favorite genius. This perhaps illustrates it better than I can in words: SPOILERS
Quote:"Sheldon," he said firmly. "I think you need to take a break." This is powerful. Immensely powerful because it invokes the, I feel, appropriate emotions in a way that is inspired. Redemption, and understanding others is the main theme and plot of the story. If for no other reason, I would reccommend it strictly because of the plot and the way it deals with it. Words can't even describe the emotions this fiction gave me as I read through it. Shenny I will briefly talk about the romance in this fiction, which is as elegant as the other facets of this fiction. Its believable, and honestly one of the best presentations of the relationship and the journey to it. It is clearly inferred that Penny does harbor a deep love for Sheldon, but it isn't something that is recognized by the blonde. Its the events in the story that help intimate this as well as grow the feelings. The prose is one again, perfect for this. Quote:When she woke up in the morning, still resting on the leather couch, she had been covered by a blanket. She could tell by the hospital corners that it was Sheldon's handiwork. The last two sentences summarized the beautify in which this love is show, intimated and finally recognized. Its not just the well-written thoughts of the characters that get the message of deep love accross, but also their interactions, specifically those between Penny and Sheldon that are prominently featured in the whole entire story. One of the most power occurs in Chapter 3 when Penny is interacting with Sheldon as he works. SPOILERS
Quote:"Sheldon," she said, as he handed her the now clean knife and made as if to move back to his scribbling. "May I ask you a question?" When I first read this, I was awed. I was struck dumb by the sheer beauty of this interaction. Not only was it beautiful, but was instense, profound, and it revealed sides of both characters that are never touched on in the main media, nay, sides that are barely touched on in other written fanfiction. The best thing, the love and attraction doesn't need to be stated, its showed throughout this wonderful work of art. That's what makes this some mesmerizing, because I can see the love, even if Penny can't yet. It also feels genuine, as all the interactions between the characters do. That's the best bit. It really feels like two distinct people are conversing and sharing an experience that will forever be theirs. The wonderful thing about the Shenny in this fiction is that it isn't explicitly stated from the get go. There are hints littered here and there (some more obvious than others), but it isn't outright stated. All of the Shenny in the beginning is inferred, intimated, and drawn from the interactions. Its also drawn from interactions Penny has with other characters. The following is a quote from the same chapter as the quote above, and it follows that interaction. SPOILER
Quote:"Leonard," she said breathily. "Can I ask you a question?" This comparison in the quote is instigated. Penny can't help but the compare the two, because she is emotionally torn between her feelings for both. Part of knows, and feels guilty, and another part doesn't quite understand why Sheldon. But, as the fiction continuously shows us, it seems to always be Sheldon. For her, there was no one else. Basically, The Elegant Universe is a fiction that is exceeds every expectation. The major downside is that is isn't finished, and its very doubtful that it ever will be. However, I would rather experience a part of this fic than to never experience it at all. That is why I believe that you should click on the link and devote your time to immersing yourself in one of the best Shennys out there. ~SK That took forever! Hopefully you find this interesting, or at all beneficial! |